This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, The Potty School earns from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Full disclosure here.
You know the face. Legs crossed, body rigid, completely focused on anything but you. You've been sitting with your child on the potty for ten minutes. Nothing. You take them off. Accident within thirty seconds.
This is one of the most frustrating stalls in potty training — and one of the most common things I hear from parents. "She sat there forever and didn't go. The second I put underwear back on, she went all over the floor."
Here's what I want you to know before anything else: your child is not doing this to you. She discovered she has control over her own body. She's using it. That's actually developmentally right on track — even when it makes you want to pull your hair out at two in the afternoon.
The goal isn't to wrestle that control away from her. It's to make releasing feel safe, normal, and non-negotiable — in that order.
Before you can fix it, it helps to understand what's driving it. A few common reasons:
The power dynamic. Toddlers have very little say over their daily lives. We choose what they eat, what they wear, when they nap. Their body is one of the few things that's entirely theirs. When we push too hard around the potty — hovering, counting down, expressing frustration — they dig in. The harder we push, the tighter they hold.
The newness. For two-plus years, releasing in a diaper was the normal, comfortable, expected thing to do. Now we're asking for something different. That transition takes adjustment, even when the child is ready.
Fear or discomfort. If your child has had a UTI, a painful accident, or even just slipped on the seat once, she may have associated the potty with something unpleasant. One bad experience can be enough.
Distraction. A toddler deep in play will ignore every signal her body sends until it's too late. She's not being defiant — she's just three.
Constipation. This one gets overlooked. A full colon puts pressure on the bladder and makes urinating genuinely uncomfortable. If your child is also struggling with poop, address that first. We wrote a full post on it: Potty Training Constipation: What's Happening & How to Help →
This is the one I say most often and get pushed back on most often. Parents want to wait until their child "tells them" she needs to go. I understand the instinct. But here's the thing: a child who is new to potty training doesn't always recognize her own cues yet, and even when she does, she'll often override them if something more interesting is happening.
You don't ask your toddler if she wants to sit in her carseat. You tell her it's time, you buckle her in, and you drive. Potty time works the same way.
Set a rhythm — every 90 minutes, and always after meals and after waking up. Make it matter-of-fact. "Time to try the potty" is a statement, not a question. Consistency removes the negotiation, and once the routine is predictable, the resistance usually drops.
A child whose feet are dangling off the toilet cannot relax her pelvic floor. It's not stubbornness — it's physics. Feet need to be flat on the floor, or on a step stool, with knees at or above hip level. This is exactly why the Squatty Potty works so well — it puts the body in the position it was designed to eliminate in.
A low-to-the-ground potty chair solves this automatically for younger toddlers. If you're going straight to the full toilet, a good step stool isn't optional.
→ See our recommended potty seats and step stools →
This one works, and I love sharing it. Have your child blow bubbles — or a pinwheel, or even just blow air — while she's sitting on the potty.
The physical act of blowing out relaxes the pelvic floor. It's involuntary. You can't tense up to hold pee and blow out at the same time. It's a small, low-pressure thing to do while sitting, and it works more often than parents expect.
Bingo.
Warm water naturally encourages the bladder to release. If your child is really stuck — especially in the early days — a bath right before a potty attempt can be the thing that breaks the pattern. It also shifts the atmosphere from tense to relaxed, which helps more than any pep talk.
Ten minutes on the potty is too long. Two to three minutes, matter-of-fact, with something calm to do — a short book, blowing bubbles — is enough. If nothing happens, that's fine. Off she comes. Try again at the next scheduled time.
The longer a sit becomes, the more charged it feels. Charge creates resistance. Keep it ordinary.
More fluid in means more urge to go. If your child isn't drinking enough water, the signals are weaker and less frequent. Getting enough water into a toddler is its own art form — we have a post on that too.
Sometimes the holding pattern becomes entrenched — weeks in, nothing is moving. That's when a fresh perspective helps more than another strategy swap.
This is exactly what a potty training consultation is for. Not because you've failed — but because sometimes you're too close to it to see what's actually driving the pattern. We've worked with enough families to spot it quickly and tell you specifically what to change.
Some insurance plans even cover our services. You can read about that here →
Is it normal for toddlers to hold pee when potty training?Yes — it's one of the most common stalls we see. It usually comes down to some mix of new-situation adjustment, body awareness still developing, and the child asserting control. It's temporary when handled well.
How long should I let my toddler sit on the potty?Two to three minutes is plenty. Longer sits create pressure and anxiety, which makes releasing harder. Keep it short, calm, and consistent.
My toddler won't pee on the potty but has accidents in underwear — what's happening?She's likely releasing as a reflex once the "holding" becomes too much — not because she chose the potty. The fix is tightening the schedule so you're catching her before the urge builds to the point of overflow. More frequent, shorter potty sits; more water; less waiting.
Maybe your child is afraid of the large toilet. Perhaps they are deeply focused on their toys. Maybe they are simply locked in a power struggle with you. Children learn through modeling and connection, but they also protect their autonomy.
Fixing this habit requires a clear plan of action. We need to focus on what to do with your hands to help your child physically relax and release their bladder. Here are the tactical steps to break the holding habit.
Get a proper, low-to-the-ground potty chair. Your child must have their feet flat on the floor to physically relax their pelvic muscles. High toilets leave legs dangling, which causes physical tension in the lower body. Skip the fancy electronic gadgets, bathroom screens, and toy baskets. You want a focused, calm environment. Read a simple book together while they sit. This keeps their body in place without overstimulating their brain.
Do not wait for your toddler to tell you they need to go. Waiting until a child feels ready is a marketing-driven abdication of parental leadership. You are the parent. Set a schedule and transition them to the bathroom every ninety minutes, especially after they drink fluids. Make it a normal, non-negotiable part of the day. Consistent transitions reduce the instinct to hold pee because the routine becomes predictable.
When a child holds their pee, their entire body tenses up. You cannot force those muscles to open, but you can trigger them naturally. Have your child blow bubbles or a pinwheel while trying to go. The physical act of blowing out automatically relaxes the pelvic floor muscles. Boom. Plop, there it was. You can also try a warm bath right before potty time. Warm water naturally encourages the bladder to release. When they finally let go and succeed, look at them with warm pride. Awh.
Potty training a constipated child is nearly impossible. If the colon is packed, the bladder cannot function properly. Give your child a diet rich in natural fiber like fruits, vegetables, and whole grains. Ensure they drink plenty of water throughout the day to make the urge to go stronger. If you suspect a medical issue is causing the block, consult your pediatrician immediately.
potty training help to be covered by insurance to help with more ongoing potty training issues..png)
Still stuck after trying these? Book a consultation → or join our Diapers to Flush membership → for ongoing support.
If the physical blocks are cleared and the habit remains, you are dealing with a behavioral stand-off. Children are intelligent humans, right? They know exactly how to maintain the status quo when they feel insecure about a new milestone.
If you are implementing these tactical steps and still hitting a wall, you do not have to figure it out alone. At The Potty School, we provide personalized consulting to map out a specific routine for your family. We work with you to analyze the timing, the triggers, and the behavioral responses. Some insurance plans even cover our services to help with ongoing issues.
Anyway, moving on. Take a deep breath, clear the calendar, and lead your child with calm certainty. They are capable, and you are entirely qualified to guide them.
~ Michelle, of The Potty School